Does Domain Knowledge Really Matter?

Home  >  Articles  > 
Does Domain Knowledge Really Matter?

Tom L. Barnett, PMP

October 20, 2008





Get three or more project managers together to discuss what makes for a good set of PM skills and you will invariably end up with a time-honored and age-worn debate. This seems to be just as fertile of an area for differences as is the debate about how much value a PM certification really adds. Debates are great: I love how passionate each side gets as they state their case. The area that I think sparks one of the most interesting discussions is:
 
“Which is more important to project manager success: domain knowledge or project management skills?”
 
It’s a gripping argument that has people all across this great land and the world lined up on both sides of the issue. People engaged in this fierce game of rock-paper-scissors steadfastly believe that there is a rational answer to it, but I have often wondered what the bottom line answer really is.
 
To start looking, I limited my scope to a core scenario--a project manager is taking the over a new project in a new company and in a different area, field or industry.



Please login/register to read the entire article.





sponsored announcements and special offers
CA Technologies' Innovation Management survey is a study into the barriers to innovation success and the measures companies are taking to improve performance. Each survey respondent will receive a complimentary copy of the report containing the survey's results. Please participate now!

Build and deploy interactive reports and dashboards — without any hidden costs. Our in-the-cloud free trial lets you see for yourself — no download required. SAP Crystal Reports Server 60-day Free Trial

Enable Agile Process; Support Agile Teams
CollabNet announces ScrumWorks Pro 4.4. As intuitive as Scrum itself, this version offers improvements in estimation and integration to CollabNet TeamForge. Improve your Scrum team's performance, enable tracking, view reports instantly, and effectively manage your Agile projects. Request a Trial

Enterprise hardware and software evolve faster than your customers can consume new versions and features. Overcome this gap: learn how professional services can boost product consumption and speed repurchasing in TSIA/Compuware white paper. Read now

Packaged Services Success: Join us on Sept 8 for this Free Webinar as RTM Consulting and Tenrox discuss the competitive and financial benefits of Leveraging Automation to meet the Rising Demand for Productized Professional Services. EARN 1 PDU. Register Here Today to receive a Free White Paper.



"Next week there can't be any crisis. My schedule is already full."
- Henry Kissinger